Confirmed Tear

I knew it later that day, when I went to stand up, there was a pop and suddenly I had a sharp pain on the inside of my left knee. This was the result of my first soccer game I had played in close to 8 months. Why I have had to put up with the medical establishment’s red tape for well over a month until FINALLY getting a referral for an MRI. My physical therapist also had good idea my injury was more severe than “osteoarthritis” as my orthopedic surgeon cited, the first time he met with me for about 5 minutes.

I believe today’s appointment with the orthopedic surgeon surpassed that of three other visits in terms of the amount of time he spent with me. He pulled up my MRI and told me the bad news. Much like I confirmed…a month ago, I had torn my meniscus. Do I know my body or what? He went on to explain what a meniscus does and said we had to option for surgery.

Unfortunately the surgery comes at a price. He called the medial meniscus tear “major” in terms of how much of the meniscus is actually remaining, which is very little. The good news, only about 20% of you meniscus provides circulation into the knee, as I understand it. So, while much of the blood flow will be restricted, once the tear is removed, the inflammation should subside and the pain will go away.

The bad news, much chance for arthritis in my knee has increased with the removal of the meniscus, which acts as a shock absorber to cushion the femur and tibia. What a minute? Didn’t he tell me a few months back I already had osteoarthritis? Yeah, he did. I guess the MRI changed his opinion and I was misdiagnosed initially. Of course, I didn’t bring that second meeting up, maybe I should have, but in the end what would I have gained?

So I have elected to have surgery. As explained to me, it’s a 30 minute procedure with 3 incisions around my left kneecap. I will leave the procedure and from his words, be able to walk and put pressure on the knee. I don’t expect to miss, but maybe a single day of work this time around. Unfortunately soccer is not official over. I won’t lace up the boots or don the jersey between the sticks. It’s been fun, but it’s time to get into coaching and let my son have all the fun.

I did find a few articles on a system called FAST-FIX Meniscal Repair System. No idea if this is even an option, but I did find a “technical guide” on how to accomplish the repair, which looks like they tie up the torn portion of the meniscus. Guess I will have to inquire about it.

Behind Door #2

Many people I talk to don’t understand why I have given up meat…and dairy…and oil. All they hear is, “you are vegan?” I don’t even try to explain a plant-based, whole foods lifestyle. It relates to FINALLY, after 42 years deciding to take my health out of the hands of doctors and into my own hands. While I haven’t been severely sick or injured often, I have used medical services in the past. Unfortunately, it comes as no surprise the level of service provided seems to be deteriorating. “Seven years ago, the World Health Organization made the first major effort to rank the health systems of 191 nations. France and Italy took the top two spots; the United States was a dismal 37th” (source). It is estimated that the US spends $2 trillion annually on healthcare expenses (source).

As I have read in The China Study by T. Colin Campbell and some papers written by Dr. John McDougall much of this expenditure is not geared towards nutrition or prevention. “The health insurance companies and the big pharmaceutical corporations are raking in gigantic mountains of cash and yet the quality of the health care that we receive in return is rather quite poor” (source). The numbers are staggering when you look at the quality of medical care many individuals receive.

Unfortunately a good many number of doctors and medical facilities are not about finding the root cause of an illness, when they can prescribe medication or invasive surgery. “Nearly half of all Americans now use prescription drugs on a regular basis according to a CDC report that was recently released. According to the report, approximately one-third of all Americans use two or more pharmaceutical drugs, and more than ten percent of all Americans use five or more drugs on a regular basis.” It does not have to be this way for a majority of people. Yet doctors don’t want to see healthy people, since they don’t make them or “Big Pharma” any money. Only sick people do. (NOTE: Here are 50 U.S. Healthcare Statistics That Will Absolutely Astonish You)

Thanks to diet (or radical lifestyle change, as seen by many of my friends) I am now on the road to a healthy lifestyle. I feel great! Unfortunately I am still battling a left knee injury from soccer that has slowed me down for the past 40 days. During that time I have been to the doctor’s office twice, seen the orthopedic surgeon three times (totaling 12 minutes), gone through 3 weeks of physical therapy and finally, yesterday received my referral for an MRI. In my opinion that should of happened about 3 weeks ago. Then again, I am not a doctor.

As I wrote a few days ago, the physical therapist is of the opinion I have a mensical tear, NOT osteoarthritis as diagnosed by the orthopedic about 3 weeks ago. The pain has yet to improve when going through physical therapy. So in the words of my orthopedic surgeon, “congratulations you win what’s behind door number two.” That being an MRI. We will see what, if anything the MRI reveals. I am still of the opinion there is something torn in the knee and physical therapy confirmed by nagging feeling. I am still shocked at the lack of complacency by the orthopedic surgeon. To show he did care, he inquired about the numbness in my right knee, which had the ACL replaced in 2009 and tingling in my right toes. Needless to say, the numbness is still there, but he was happy to hear the tingling went away. Thanks doc! Guess I am the first to end up with a numb knee after surgery.

“Knee-d” More Information

As of today it will have been 4 sessions with the physical therapist encompassing 2 weeks. To date, I have been provided with electric stimulation, ice, ultrasound and a series of strengthening exercises for my left knee. To date, the pain still exists and while the muscles around the knee (quad,hamstring, calf) will eventually get stronger, the cause of the pain still exists. The therapists has mentioned it a few times that she doesn’t believe the underlying cause is osteoarthritis of the left knee.

While the day to day pain has subsided, there is still a pain and terrible popping noise when I walk, this is especially noticeable when climbing stairs. Even sitting with the knee in a bent position or lying down with my legs straight out will eventually increase the severity of pain. While the therapist cannot come out and tell the orthopedic surgeon how to do his job, she does recommend I push for an MRI of the left knee.

On the recommendation of a user at the McDougall Forums, I picked up a book by Pete Egoscue called Pain Free: A Revolutionary Method for Stopping Chronic Pain. This book attempts to get to the root cause of the pain through a series of exercises and stretching routines called “E-cises.” Only a few chapters in and one comments from the author stood out. “The musculoskeletal system’s worst enemy…is the x-ray machine. With one stroke of technological genius, we went from observing the body from the outside with sharp eyes to scrutinizing it with a specialized instrument from inside.” This rings true with my trip to the orthopedic surgeon. A quick 3-4 minute discussion while looking at the x-ray and I was on my way. Never did his hands or eyes feel or see my knee, except via the x-ray.

I won’t take the orthopedic up on his recommendation for a series of injections that may or may not work. That would (if successful) only provide a stop gap and not get to the root cause of the problem, must like Pete Egoscue stresses in his book. Therapy has gone about as far as it can, progress isn’t being made and the therapist recommends “further work up” as she called it. Reading between the lines, she wants to see an MRI.

Coincidence?: Part V – The Referral

So it took two office visits, $30 and 8 days, but I finally got what I was after. Then again in my opinion I should of had that referral last Monday when I met with the nurse practitioner. Still the end result, which isn’t truly the end, more like the beginning because I will have to go through a similar process when I visit the orthopedic surgeon next Tuesday. This is the same doctor who operated on my right ACL nearly 3 years ago. Funny, but to this day the knee is still numb…

With the referral in my hand, I will have to give up going on vacation with my wife, son and mother-in-law. It was going to be my first visit to SoCal in 7 years! Hard to believe it’s been that long. I cannot put off the office visit with the orthopedic surgeon if indeed there is more to my knee injury. The nurse practitioner did seem pretty confident I had a torn meniscus, but still unsure as the severity of the injury to the MCL.

So today was a step in the right direction. We will see what happens next. I just find it really weird this playing out similar to what happened in 2009 when I tore the ACL. I am guessing the orthopedic surgeon will request an MRI, which will probably happen Tuesday of next week, followed by another office visit. Chances are IF surgery is required it will happen before the end of March. Fingers crossed we will see what he has to say next week